| YEAR | RESULT |
| 1998 | Mark O'Meara (4-4-5-4) def. Brian Watts (5-4-5-5) in four holes at Royal Birkdale, Southport, England. |
| 1995 | John Daly (3-4-4-4--15) def. Costantino Rocca (5-4-7-3--19) in four holes at St. Andrews, St. Andrews, Scotland |
| 1989 | Mark Calcavecchia (4-3-3-3--13) def. Wayne Grady (4-4-4-4--16) and Greg Norman (3-3-4-x) in four holes at Royal Troon, Troon, Scotland |
| 1975 | Tom Watson (71) def. Jack Newton (72) at Carnoustie, Carnoustie, Scotland |
| 1970 | Jack Nicklaus (72) def. Doug Sanders (73) at St. Andrews, St. Andrews, Scotland |
| 1963 | Bob Charles (140) def. Phil Rodgers (148) in 36 holes at Royal Lytham, Lytham, England |
| 1958 | Peter Thomson (139) def. Dave Thomas (143) in 36 holes at Royal Lytham, Lytham, England |
| 1949 | Bobby Locke (135) def. Harry Bradshaw (147) in 36 holes at Royal St. George's, Sandwich, England |
| 1933 | Denny Shute (149) def. Craig Wood (154) in 36 holes at St. Andrews, St. Andrews, Scotland |
| 1921 | Jack Hutchison (150) def. Roger Wethered (159) in 36 holes at St. Andrews, St. Andrews, Scotland |
| 1911 | Harry Vardon won when Arnaud Massy conceded at the 35th hole at Royal St. George's, Sandwich, England |
| 1896 | Harry Vardon (157) def. J.H. Taylor (161) in 36 holes at Muirfield, Gullane, Scotland |
| 1889 | Willie Park, Jr. (158) def. Andrew Kirkaldy (163) in 36 holes at Musselburgh, Musselburgh, Scotland |
| 1883 | Willie Fernie (158) def. Bob Ferguson (159) in 36 holes at Musselburgh, Musselburgh, Scotland |
| 1876 | Bob Martin awarded title when David Strath refused playoff at St. Andrews, St. Andrews, Scotland |