College Football
Friday, December 31
Chalk Talk: Alexander vs. Thomas
ESPN.com

The Matchup:
Shaun Alexander vs. Anthony Thomas

The Game:
Alabama vs. Michigan Saturday on ABC, 8:30 p.m. ET.

The Question:
Who is the better running back, Shaun Alexander or Anthony Thomas?

Shaun Alexander   Anthony Thomas
 
HT: 6-1 | WT: 220 | AGE: 22 | YR: Senior

By Rodney Gilmore
Special to ESPN.com

I like Shaun Alexander against the Michigan defense more than I like Anthony Thomas going against the Alabama defense. Alexander is the more versatile back, scoring touchdowns this season in three different ways: rushing, receiving and returning a kick.

Michigan doesn't get the same production out of Thomas in the running game. In fact, the Wolverines have had one of their worst seasons running the ball in their history, averaging 115 yards a game. That's not a typical Michigan team running the football.

Alexander, meanwhile, rushed for 1,383 yards -- averaging 126 a game -- and 19 rushing touchdowns. People think that he is not a powerful back, that he is more of a shifty runner. But Alexander is a slasher. He can run between the tackles and is also great on the toss sweep. Plus, he can catch the ball; he had 25 receptions, four for touchdowns.

Alexander is healthy going into the Orange Bowl. He has recovered from his sprained ankle, giving him the advantage in one-on-one matchups against Michigan linebackers Ian Gold and Dhani Jones and strong safety Tommy Hendricks. He can make catches down the field and stretch the defense. That's a unique quality to find in a running back.

Receiver Freddie Milons will stretch the Michigan defense and open up the running game for Alexander. But one potential problem could be the absence of All-America tackle Chris Samuels, who is questionable with a sore knee. That may hurt the running attack, but it wouldn't eliminate Alexander's ability to have a strong performance.

  HT: 6-2 | WT: 221 | AGE: 22 | YR: Junior

By Bill Curry
Special to ESPN.com

When practice got under way last April, I got a phone call. "Bill, I don't know about the offense, but this defense can run. We have speed." My Tuscaloosa, Ala., source was right, as usual. The Michigan Wolverines will see the fastest defense they have faced this season in their Orange Bowl date with Alabama.

Great speed complicates game plans. Protecting the passer, running the ball outside, and executing today's sophisticated screen game -- those weapons can be stopped by 11 people who can run and tackle. That leaves one basis for an offensive plan: Take a big, tough offensive line, a great back like Anthony Thomas with guts and come off the football for 60 minutes, mixing a good dose of play-action passing.

Midway through this season, we might have figured the line and the play-action were present, with the back a huge question mark. No more. The A-Train is operating on time, and the derailed Wolverines of October are once again chugging toward a fast finish, riding a four-game winning streak.

Thomas has come of age. Consider: In the last five games, in a display of power, speed and endurance, he has carried 145 times, gained 735 yards and scored nine touchdowns. He has had as many as 42 carries in a single game, has blocked, caught passes and led his team into a BCS game.

The Alabama defense realizes that all its speed will come to naught if the Tide cannot untrack the A-train.

ESPN.com: Help | Ad Info | Contact | Tools | Site Map
Copyright ©1999 ESPN Internet Ventures. Terms of Use and Privacy Policy are applicable to this site. Click here for a list of employment opportunities at ESPN.com.


Consolation contest? Not exactly, say Orange Bowl teams

Happy ending to tumultuous year for Alabama coach

War Room: Orange Bowl preview

FedEx Orange Bowl

Chalk Talk: Vick vs. Weinke

Chalk Talk: Crouch vs. Martin


video
 Anthony Thomas marches in untouched for the TD. (Courtesy: ABC)
avi: 502 k
RealVideo: 56.6 | ISDN | T1

 Shaun Alexander goes in for his second score of the game.
avi: 812 k
RealVideo: 56.6 | ISDN | T1

 Anthony Thomas dives for the TD.(Courtesy:ABC)
avi: 455 k
RealVideo: 56.6 | ISDN | T1

 Shaun Alexander ties the game on an 8-yard touchdown run.
avi: 486 k
RealVideo: 56.6 | ISDN | T1

ESPN NETWORK: ABC Sports | Fantasy | Store | Insider
.